Court Judgments & Orders · न्यायालयीन निर्णय
Maharashtra State Excise case law — Supreme Court, Bombay HC, tribunals. Includes the uploaded Court Orders.
167judgments
New this week: 5
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
18 Nov 2019
Hotel Shyamshankar Bar and Restaurant v. State of Maharashtra (Consolidated Yavatmal and Akola Petitions)
Consolidated petition by 33 bar, restaurant, and country liquor licence holders challenging denial or cancellation of foreign liquor and country liquor licences by Maharashtra excise authorities in Yavatmal and Akola districts.
Ratio: Cour...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Chandrashekhar Mishrilal Katakwar & Others v. State of Maharashtra (Excise Licensing Validity Challenge)
on 13 November, 2019
Multiple writ petitions by foreign liquor and country liquor licensees challenging the validity of excise licensing decisions and distance/proximity conditions prescribed by the State of Maharashtra under the Bombay Prohibition Act and Maha...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Nandlal Narumal Sugwani and Others v. State of Maharashtra
Multiple bar, restaurant, and liquor shop proprietors challenged excise license cancellations and distance requirements imposed under Maharashtra excise law. The judgment addresses the validity of excise orders affecting foreign liquor and...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Smt. Seema Manoj Jaiswal And Others vs State of Maharashtra (Liquor License Distance Requirement)
Multiple writ petitions challenging cancellation/rejection of liquor licenses on grounds of non-compliance with distance requirements under excise rules. Petitioners (bar, restaurant and country liquor shop operators) challenged State's enf...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Multiple Petitioners v. State of Maharashtra (Hotel Radhika & Others)
2019 (173) 1.wp.3150-17
Multiple consolidated writ petitions challenging liquor license cancellations and excise administrative actions affecting foreign liquor and country liquor shops in Nagpur, Bhandara, Washim and Amravati districts. Bench considered validity...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Vijay Bardrilal Jaiswal And Another v. The State Of Maharashtra
Multiple writ petitions challenging distance criteria and location conditions imposed by State Excise for grant and renewal of liquor licenses under Maharashtra Excise law. Petitioners (bar/restaurant and country liquor shop operators) chal...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
R.D. Wines, M/S Raman Distilleries and Others v. State of Maharashtra
Multiple alcohol license holders challenged various excise regulatory decisions affecting FL-BR, FL-III, and CL-III licenses across Nagpur, Bhandara, Washim, and Amravati districts. The court examined compliance with distance/locational res...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
★ Landmark
13 Nov 2019
Kwality Wine Shop v. State of Maharashtra
Multiple bar, restaurant and liquor shop licence holders challenged excise licence cancellation/suspension orders and PWD distance restriction orders under BPA and Maharashtra Excise Rules. Consolidated hearing of 18 writ petitions from Bha...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Santosh S/O Shriramlal Jaiswal v. State of Maharashtra
Analysis pending · Full text available / विश्लेषण प्रलंबित
Santosh S/O Shriramlal Jaiswal vs The State Of Maharashtra, Thr. ... on 13 November, 2019 Bench: R.K.Deshpande, Milind N. Jadhav 1.wp.3150-17 (173)-Judg. 1/180 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH, NAGP...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
S.K. Pant & Others v. State of Maharashtra & Others
<UNKNOWN>
Multiple writ petitions challenging cancellation/refusal of foreign liquor (FL) and country liquor (CL) licenses by excise authorities on distance-based grounds and structural requirements. The petitioners disputed the mandatory application...
Bombay High Court
· Nagpur
13 Nov 2019
Hotel Jaiswal Wine Bar v. State of Maharashtra
Multiple liquor license holders challenged enforcement orders denying or cancelling foreign liquor and country liquor retail licenses based on distance restrictions from schools and educational institutions under Maharashtra excise policy....
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Mina Dinesh Jaiswal And Others v. State of Maharashtra (Multiple Writ Petitions on Distance Requirements)
<UNKNOWN>
Multiple consolidated writ petitions by licensed liquor retailers challenging distance requirements mandated by PWD for bars, restaurants, and country liquor shops in Nagpur, Bhandara, Washim, and Amravati districts. Core dispute concerns t...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Bhaskar Gulabrao Atole And Another vs The State Of Maharashtra, Thr. ... on 13 November, 2019
Analysis pending · Full text available / विश्लेषण प्रलंबित
1.wp.3150-17 (173)-Judg. 1/180
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
WRIT PETITION NO. 3150 OF 2017
PETITIONERS :- 1. Amrut Bar & Restaurant, Nakadongari,
Tah. Tumsar, Dist. Bhandara,
T...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Nov 2019
Neelam Hotel And Food Products v. Collector, Amravati
Multiple writ petitions challenging State Excise Department's distance and location restrictions for liquor retail establishments (bars, restaurants, wine shops) in districts including Bhandara, Washim, Nagpur, and Amravati. Petitioners que...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
11 Apr 2019
Subash Soman vs State of Kerala
2009 (1) KHC 522; 1988 (2) KLT 261
Analysis pending · Full text available / विश्लेषण प्रलंबित
Subash Soman vs State Of Kerala on 11 April, 2019 Author: Anil K.Narendran Bench: Anil K.Narendran IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN THURSDAY, THE 11TH DAY OF AP...
Supreme Court
17 Jan 2019
Indian Hotel And Restaurant ... vs The State Of Maharashtra Home ... on 17 January, 2019
Analysis pending · Full text available / विश्लेषण प्रलंबित
1
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 576 OF 2016
INDIAN HOTEL AND RESTAURANT
ASSOCIATION (AHAR) & ANR. .....APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MAHA...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
13 Dec 2018
Sou. Kamlabai Kallappa Kumasage v. The Collector, Sangli
Writ petition challenging cancellation of FL-III liquor licence under BPA Section 56(1)(b) withdrawn with liberty to file appeal. Court found the order appealable under Section 137 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, directing petitioner to purs...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
08 Oct 2018
Subhash Nanhalal Gupta And Anr vs The State Of Maharashtra on 8 October, 2018
Analysis pending · Full text available / विश्लेषण प्रलंबित
APL496-16.doc
SSK
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 496 OF 2016
1. Subhash Nanhalal Gupta
Gupta Paints & Hardware, Shop no.9,
Plot no.323/324, S. V...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
★ Landmark
13 Feb 2018
Suryakant @ Mukesh Laxman Dhotre v. The Commissioner of Police, Solapur
Detention order under MPDA Act 1981 quashed where detaining authority vitiated subjective satisfaction by considering chemical analysis reports and forensic opinion from six earlier liquor offences (CR Nos. 6056/15, 6072/15, 6092/15, 190/16...
Bombay High Court
· Principal Seat
10 Jan 2018
Radhesham Sriram Jaiswal v. State of Maharashtra
Country liquor shop licensees challenged the September 1, 2017 notification amending Rule 24(4) of the Maharashtra Country Liquor Rules, 1973, which introduced new eligibility conditions (25 sq. meters minimum area, parking, non-agricultura...